://BacklinkURLs

Vetting a site before you pay

Guest post vetting checklist: a scorecard with pass and fail lines

Guest post vetting checklist

Most guest post checklists are lists of things to "consider". This one has lines. Each check says what to look at, where the pass line sits, and what a fail costs you, so two people scoring the same site get the same answer.

The lines are the ones we use on our own lists, plus a few rules of thumb where we say so. You can print this page, or download the scorecard as a spreadsheet file at the end.

How the scorecard works

Guest post checklistGuest post checklist
Knockouts first, points second, then one of three decisions.

Part 1 is five checks that end the review on the spot. Do them first, in the order shown, because the early ones are free and take minutes.

Part 2 is ten checks scored 0, 1 or 2. They separate a good site from one that merely survived Part 1. Add them up for a score out of 20.

Part 1: the five knockout checks

Fail any one of these and stop. No score in Part 2 makes up for it.

CheckHow to check itKnockout when
1. Loads on its own domainOpen the homepage and watch the address bar.It errors, or redirects to a different domain.
2. No gray topicsOpen the sitemap and search post addresses for casino, betting, CBD, crypto, vaping, payday loans, adult and essay writing. Then search the site itself for the same words.Any of them turns up.
3. Enough search trafficTake the latest 3-month average of estimated Google visits and of ranking keywords.Under 500 visits a month, or under 100 keywords.
4. No traffic collapseDivide the latest 3 months by the best 3 months in the last 24.The answer is under 30%.
5. Recent posts are indexedSearch Google for the exact address of 3 posts from the last 3 months.2 or more are missing.

Checks 1, 2 and 5 cost nothing. Checks 3 and 4 need a tool that estimates traffic history, so do them after the free ones.

How to vet a guest post siteHow to vet a guest post site
The shape of the line matters more than this month's number.

Before you fail a site on check 4, look at the same months a year earlier. Home and garden sites dip every winter. If the site is within 80% of where it was in those months last year, treat the drop as seasonal.

How often sites fail these checks

The traffic checks are the ones that catch sites which look fine. A website may have a clean design, on-topic posts and a prompt response from the owner, yet still have lost the majority of its readers.

Part 2: the ten scored checks

Each check is worth 2 points. On the starred rows, the line between 1 point and 0 (or knockout) is the threshold on our methodology page. Every other line is a rule of thumb we find workable. Move them if your niche requires it, but make the decision before you review the site, not after.

Check2 points1 point0 points
1. Traffic level*2,000+ visits a month500 to 2,000Knockout
2. Traffic direction*Latest 3 months within 20% of the 3 before, or seasonalDown more than 20%Knockout if under 30% of peak
3. Keyword trendRanking keywords flat or risingFallingKnockout if under 100
4. Domain historyContinuous archive, same subject throughoutOne old gap or change of subjectRecent revival: near zero a year ago, busy now
5. Outbound links per post*8 or fewer9 to 15Over 15
6. Sponsored share*Under 10% of the 20 newest posts10% to 30%Over 30%
7. Article length*800+ words on average500 to 800Under 500
8. Posting rate*12 or more posts in 12 months4 to 113 or fewer
9. On your subject8 or more of the 10 newest posts5 to 74 or fewer
10. Seller terms in writingPermanence, rel attribute and replacement all answeredSome answeredRefuses to put anything in writing

For checks 5 to 9, read the newest posts and count inside the article body only. Menus, footers and author boxes do not count.

Check 10 is the only one that needs the seller. Ask three questions: how long the post stays up, which rel attribute the link carries, and what happens if the link is removed. Our guide to seller terms has the full list.

Reading the score

Guest post vetting scorecardGuest post vetting scorecard
Decide the bands before you score, and stick to them.
ScoreDecisionWhy
16 to 20Buy at the asking priceNo more than two weak points, and nothing serious.
11 to 15Buy only at a lower price, or passSeveral soft spots. The price should reflect them.
0 to 10Walk awayToo many weak points for any price to fix.

The bands are our policy, not a law. Their job is to stop you talking yourself into a site because the seller was friendly or the price was low.

A worked example

This site is invented to show the arithmetic.

Illustrative figures only.
CheckWhat was foundPoints
Knockouts 1 to 5All passedGo on
Traffic level3,400 visits a month2
Traffic directionDown 24% in 3 months, not seasonal1
Keyword trendFlat2
Domain historyContinuous since 2016, same subject2
Outbound links11 per post1
Sponsored share4 of 20 posts (20%)1
Article length1,100 words2
Posting rate31 posts in 12 months2
On your subject9 of 102
Seller termsPermanence and rel answered, replacement not1
Total16 of 20

By a single point, sixteen is a buy. The three single-point answers tell you what to do next: ask about replacement, and re-check traffic in a month before ordering a second post.

The order that saves money

Guest post site checksGuest post site checks
Each stage costs more than the one before, so fewer sites should reach it.

In our run, 1.8% of checked sites came through the free checks. Paying for traffic data on all of them would have meant buying data on thousands of sites that a sitemap search would have removed for nothing.

The same principle applies to your time. Do not write to a seller until the site has passed every knockout you can run without them.

What the scorecard cannot tell you

  • Whether your post will be indexed. Check 5 looks at the site's recent record. Page-level indexing checks go further.
  • Whether the link will stay. Ahrefs found that in about a third of lost links, the page is still live and the link was removed. Written terms and re-checks are your only defence. See the guide to how backlinks pass value.
  • Whether the link is within Google's rules. Google's spam policies treat links bought for ranking purposes as link spam unless they carry rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". A high score does not change that.

How to check this yourself

  1. Set your bands first. Write down the score you will buy at before you open the site.
  2. Run knockouts 1, 2 and 5. They are free: load the site, search the sitemap, and search Google for three recent post addresses.
  3. Pull 24 months of traffic and keywords for the sites still standing, and run knockouts 3 and 4.
  4. Read the 10 newest posts and score checks 5 to 9 as you go.
  5. Look the domain up in the web archive for check 4. Look at one capture per year.
  6. Email the seller the three terms questions and score check 10 from the reply.
  7. Add it up and apply the band you wrote down in step 1.
  8. Keep the scorecard. Re-score the site before any repeat order.

Download the scorecard (CSV)

Questions buyers ask

Is a high DR or DA enough to skip the checklist?
No. DR (Ahrefs Domain Rating) and DA (Moz Domain Authority) score a whole domain and say nothing about traffic direction, gray-topic posts or whether recent pages are indexed. None of the 15 checks uses them.
What if the seller will not put terms in writing?
Score check 10 as zero and count it against the total. A seller who will not confirm how long a post stays up by email has told you something about how a later dispute would go.
Does a site that passes make a paid link safe with Google?
No. Google classes links bought for ranking purposes as link spam unless they carry rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". The scorecard reduces wasted spend. It does not change the policy.
How often should I re-score a site?
Before every repeat order, and at once if the site changes owner, design or subject. Traffic and content can fluctuate within a few months.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: spam policies for Google web search
  2. Ahrefs: link rot study

Last updated Methodology