://BacklinkURLs

How we work

How we vet sites that sell guest posts

This page describes what we check on a site before it is listed, the order we check it in, and where the pass and fail lines sit. It also tells you what we don't check, because a vetting process is only valuable if you know where it ends.

Every figure in our guides and research reports that is credited to BacklinkURLs data comes out of the process below.

What we are looking for

We list blogs that sell guest posts or link insertions and that an ordinary business could be seen on without embarrassment. In practice that means a site with real readers from Google, a steady history, on-topic writing, and no gray-topic content.

Our inventory is in home, garden, DIY, renovation and lifestyle topics. A good site outside those topics is still turned away as off topic, so our rejection figures describe this niche and should not be read as the whole web.

The order of the checks

Cheap checks run first and paid data comes last. A site that fails an early check never reaches the later ones, which is why later checks cover far fewer sites than early ones.

StepWhat we look atA site is removed when
1. Is it aliveThe homepage is requested and its title read.It does not load, returns an error, or redirects to a different domain.
2. Is it a blogHomepage text, page title and the post archive.It is a directory, a company or shop site, a tool, or anything that does not publish articles. A publishing blog needs at least 50 posts.
3. Is it on topicThe title, then the 10 newest post titles.It is not about home, garden, DIY, renovation or lifestyle subjects.
4. Gray topicsEvery post address in the sitemap, plus homepage and recent post text.We find casino, betting, poker, slots, CBD, cannabis, kratom, vaping, crypto, forex, payday loans, adult content or essay writing.
5. Can it be reachedA contact email or contact form, and whether the mailbox exists.There is no working way to reach the owner.
6. Seller answersWe write to the owner and ask for prices, bulk rate and terms.The owner does not sell placements, or does not answer.
7. Traffic history24 months of estimated Google visits and ranking keyword counts.It fails a traffic threshold below.
8. Content sampleThe 20 newest posts: outbound links, nofollow share, sponsored share, length, posting rate.Shown on the listing. Link-farm levels are flagged.
9. Domain historyRegistration date and yearly web archive captures.Shown on the listing. Long gaps are flagged as a possible recycled domain.

Traffic thresholds

Most sites that appear to be fine at first fail at the traffic level. We take three-month averages, so one unusual month doesn't dictate the result.

ResultRule
FailThe latest 3-month average is below 500 estimated Google visits a month.
FailThe latest 3-month average is below 100 ranking keywords.
FailThe latest 3 months are below 30% of the site's best 3 months in the 24-month window. The site has collapsed.
WatchTraffic is between 500 and 2,000 visits a month.
WatchThe latest 3 months are more than 20% below the 3 months before them, unless the same months a year earlier show the same dip. A site within 80% of last year's level for those months is treated as seasonal.
WatchThe site had under 50 visits a month a year ago and has more than 1,000 now. A jump like that can mean an expired domain brought back to sell links.
SteadyNone of the above.

A site tagged Watch may still be listed. The listing states which rule it tripped, so you can decide if the price is worth it.

What the content sample measures

We read the 20 newest posts on a site and count, inside the article body only:

  • Outbound links per post and the share that are nofollow. More than 15 per post is link-farm territory.
  • Sponsored share: how many of those posts are labelled sponsored or guest. Above 30% the site is mostly selling.
  • Words per post. Under 500 on average is thin.
  • Posting rate. Three or fewer posts in 12 months is a quiet site, and we say so on the listing.

Prices and seller terms

We ask each seller the same questions by email: the price of a guest post and of a link insertion, the rate for several links at once, whether links are dofollow, whether the post is labelled sponsored, how long it stays up, turnaround and payment. The listing shows their answers and the date they answered.

We don't add a markup, we don't collect a commission, and we don't bargain for you, other than to ask for the bulk rate. You write to the seller at the same address we used.

Seller answers are assertions, and we have not verified them through a purchase. A seller who says a link is permanent has said so in an email, and that is all.

Data sources

  • The site itself: homepage, sitemap, feed and recent posts, fetched directly.
  • Third-party traffic estimates: monthly estimated Google visits and ranking keyword counts over 24 months.
  • Public registration records for domain age.
  • The public web archive for yearly capture history.
  • AI answers: where we have seen an AI system cite the site, the listing shows it.
  • The seller, by email, for prices and terms.

What we do not check

  • Authority scores. We do not list a site because of its DR (Ahrefs Domain Rating), DA (Moz Domain Authority) or any similar score, and we do not reject one for a low score.
  • The site's own backlink profile. We do not audit who links to the seller.
  • Google indexing of every site. Where an index check was run, the listing shows it with its date. It is not run on every site.
  • Who the seller is. We do not verify identity or ownership beyond the fact that they answer from an address found on the site.
  • Whether a placement will work. We do not buy test links, and we do not track placements after you buy.
  • Google policy compliance. Buying links to influence rankings is against Google's spam policies unless the link carries rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". Our checks reduce wasted money. They do not make a paid link safe.

Known limitations

  • Traffic figures are estimates modelled from search rankings. They are useful for the shape of a trend and can be well off a site's real analytics.
  • The gray-topic scan matches words. It can miss content that avoids the obvious terms, and a clean result means none of our terms were found.
  • The content sample is 20 posts. Older parts of a large site may look different.
  • Each check is a point in time. Sites change ownership, prices go up and content changes after our date.
  • Our sample is one niche and one way of finding sites, so percentages in our reports describe the sites we looked at.

Why site names are not published

Our guides and research reports never name the sites behind a figure, pass or fail. Results are shown as counts, shares, ranges and medians, and any group of fewer than 20 sites is left out. If we were to name a site, it would draw visitors and attention to that site, and that could skew the very metrics we are trying to measure.

If you need the sites behind a published figure to check our work, write to us and we can share them privately.

How often lists are refreshed

Members get a new list of 30 sites each month. A site is checked once, when we collect it, and each check on the listing shows the date it was run. Past lists are sold as they were and are not checked again, so check anything older yourself before you pay.

How to check this yourself

  1. Open the sitemap. Add /sitemap.xml to the domain and search the post addresses for casino, cbd, crypto, betting and loan.
  2. Read the 10 newest posts. Note the topics, the dates, and how many links each one gives out.
  3. Pull 24 months of traffic from any tool that estimates it. Compare the latest 3 months with the best 3 months. Under 30% is a collapse.
  4. Check the same months last year before you call a drop a decline. Home and garden sites dip every winter.
  5. Look the domain up in the web archive. A gap of a year or more, or a change of subject, points to a recycled domain.
  6. Ask the seller in writing for the price, the bulk rate, the rel attribute, how long the post stays up and what happens if it is removed.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: spam policies for Google web search

Last updated