://BacklinkURLs

For agencies

A link building QA process for agencies

Link building QA process

Agencies rarely lose clients over one bad link. They lose them when a client finds a casino post beside their brand and the agency cannot say how the site was chosen.

This is a process you can adopt as written. It uses the vetting scorecard for the judgment calls and adds the parts an agency needs: roles, sign-off and records.

What a process fixes

  • Inconsistency. Two staff judge the same site differently. A written line removes the argument.
  • Memory. Six months on, nobody recalls why a site was approved. The sheet does.
  • Pressure. Month-end targets push weak sites through. A separate approver is harder to rush.
  • Client questions. "Why this site?" has an answer with a date on it.
Link building QA processLink building QA process
Six stages. A site can leave at any of the first three.

The six stages

StageWhoWhat happensOutput
1. IntakeLink builderSite is proposed with its source and the client it is for.A new row.
2. KnockoutsLink builderFive pass or fail checks: loads, gray topics, traffic floor, no collapse, recent posts indexed.Pass, or rejected with the reason.
3. ScoringLink builderTen checks scored 0 to 2.A score out of 20.
4. Sign-offQA leadReviews the row, spot-checks two items, approves or rejects.Approved, with name and date.
5. Post-placementLink builderDay 1, day 7 and day 30 checks.Three dated results.
6. Re-checksQA lead or toolDay 90, 180, 365, then yearly.Live, indexed, link present, rel unchanged.

Stages 2 and 3 are the scorecard in the vetting checklist. Stage 5 is the post-placement checklist. Stage 6 is the re-check schedule.

Thresholds, written once

CheckAgency lineSource
Search traffic500+ estimated visits a month, 100+ ranking keywordsOur threshold
Traffic retention30% or more of the best 3 months in 24Our threshold
Gray topicsNone, anywhere in the sitemapOur threshold
Outbound linksNo more than 15 per post on averageOur threshold
Sponsored shareNo more than 30% of the 20 newest postsOur threshold
Score to buy16 of 20, or 11 to 15 with a reduced priceRule of thumb
Client relevanceSite subject matches the client'sYour call per client

These are the lines we use, published on our methodology page. Adopt them or set your own. What matters is that the line is written before the site is looked at, and that changing it means editing this table.

Two roles, kept apart

Agency link vettingAgency link vetting
The person with the target should not be the person who approves.
  • Link builder. Finds sites, runs the checks, records the evidence, places the order after approval.
  • QA lead. Did not find the site. Reviews the row, re-runs two checks at random, signs off, and owns the re-check schedule.

In a small agency the QA lead can be the account manager or the owner. The point is a second pair of eyes with no stake in the monthly count.

The record

GroupColumns
IdentitySite, client, proposed by, date, source of the site.
KnockoutsFive results, each with the evidence: the sitemap address searched, the traffic figures, the three post addresses tested.
ScoreTen scores and the total.
TermsPrice, link type, label, permanence, replacement, with the date of the seller's email.
DecisionApproved or rejected, by whom, when, and why.
PlacementAddress, date live, target page, anchor, rel on day one.
ChecksDay 1, 7, 30, 90, 180, 365: four results each.

One row per site per client. A rejected site keeps its row, so nobody proposes it again next quarter.

How many sites to expect to reject

Our intake is a broad sweep, so your reject rate on sites sourced from seller lists will be lower. Still expect most proposed sites to fail, and budget link builders' time for that. Vetting at scale covers the order that keeps the cost down.

A monthly audit

Link QA checklistLink QA checklist
Fifteen minutes that keep the process honest.
  • Pull ten approved rows at random. Is every evidence field filled in?
  • Re-run the gray-topic search on three of them.
  • Count rejections by stage. If nothing is ever rejected at sign-off, sign-off is not happening.
  • Check last month's re-checks were done on their dates.
  • Report the survival rate to clients. See reporting link quality.

How to check this yourself

  1. Copy the six stages into your own process document.
  2. Write your thresholds in one table and date it.
  3. Name a QA lead who is not responsible for link targets.
  4. Build the sheet with the column groups above.
  5. Run the next ten sites through it and time each stage.
  6. Hold the first monthly audit and fix whatever it shows.

Questions buyers ask

How long should QA take per site?
Time it in your own team. The free knockouts take minutes. The traffic checks need a data tool. Sign-off should be a short review of a completed row, not a repeat of the work.
Do small agencies need a separate QA lead?
They need a second person to approve, even if it is the owner. The separation matters more than the job title.
Should clients see the QA sheet?
Showing the checks and thresholds builds trust. Agencies often keep seller contacts and prices internal. Decide once and apply it to every client.

Sources

  1. BacklinkURLs methodology

Last updated Methodology