://BacklinkURLs

Strategy beyond outreach

Build or buy backlinks? Compare cost per live, indexed link

Build or buy backlinks

"Build or buy" is usually argued as a matter of principle. It is more useful as arithmetic. Every route has a cost, a failure rate and a risk, and they can be put side by side.

This guide gives you the measure, fills it in with the figures that exist, and is honest about the ones that do not.

The measure

Build or buy backlinksBuild or buy backlinks
A link that is gone or unindexed in a year cost you the full price for nothing.

Cost per live, indexed link = (money paid + hours × hourly rate) ÷ links live and indexed after 12 months.

Three things make this better than cost per link: it counts labour, it ignores links that died, and it ignores links Google never indexed. How backlinks pass value explains why those two failures matter most.

The four routes

RouteWhat you payWho does the workMain failure
OutreachHours, plus the seller's price if it is a paid post.You or your staff.Low reply rates. Most hours produce nothing.
Gig marketplaceA few dollars per link.The gig seller.Pages are dead, blocked or never indexed.
AgencyA fee per link or a retainer.The agency.You cannot see the sites, the markup or the checks.
Vetted listA subscription, plus the seller's price.The list does finding and vetting. You buy.Depends on the quality of the vetting.

What the figures say

Survey figures as compiled by Searchlab. Marketplace figure from SpeedyIndex.
RouteTypical money costLabourSurvival evidence
Outreach, paid postAbout $100 to the owner in our nicheHigh. See the cost model.Not measured. Depends on the sites you pick.
Gig marketplaceA few dollarsLow3.7% indexed after a year in one audit of 15,389 links.
Agency$300 to $500 is the most common cost per link reported by digital PR professionalsLowNot published. Ask the agency for theirs.
Vetted listSubscription plus the owner's priceMedium. You still contact and buy.Not measured by us.
Cost per indexed linkCost per indexed link
The marketplace figure uses the 3.7% indexing rate from the SpeedyIndex audit.

The marketplace row is the only one with a measured survival rate, and it is brutal. If 3.7% of links are indexed after a year, a $1 link costs $27 per indexed link and a $5 link costs $135. That is before asking whether the indexed ones are on pages worth anything. The marketplace guide goes through the audit.

The policy side

Confirmed by Google

Google's spam policies treat links bought for ranking purposes as link spam unless they carry rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". Links earned without payment, through outreach, PR or simply being cited, are the only kind that raise no policy question.

RoutePolicy position
Outreach for unpaid linksWithin the policy.
Any paid link tagged sponsored or nofollowWithin the policy.
Any paid link left untaggedAgainst the policy, whichever route found it.

So "build" and "buy" differ on policy only when building means unpaid. A guest post you paid for after a week of outreach is a bought link. The policy guide sets out the options.

Choosing

Link building vs buyingLink building vs buying
A rough guide. Most businesses use more than one.
If you haveLean toward
Time, no budget, and a real storyOutreach and PR for earned links.
Budget, no time, and trust in a providerAn agency. Ask to see the sites and their checks.
Some budget, some time, and want controlA vetted list, buying direct from owners.
Almost no budget and a need for volumeNone of these. Cheap volume is the route with a measured 96% failure rate.

How to check this yourself

  1. List the links you got in the last year by route.
  2. Add up money and hours for each route.
  3. Check each link: live, indexed, still there.
  4. Divide cost by surviving links for each route.
  5. Compare the figures. Put next year's budget where the number is lowest and the risk is one you accept.

Questions buyers ask

Is it better to build or buy backlinks?
Earned links carry no policy risk and are slow and labour-heavy. Bought placements are faster and are against Google's policy unless tagged. Compare them by cost per link that is still live and indexed a year later.
What is the cheapest way to get backlinks?
Per link, gig marketplaces. Per link that survives and is indexed, they are among the most expensive, on the one audit that measured it.
Are agencies worth the price?
They can be, if they show you the sites, their checks and their survival record. The fee buys their labour and judgment. Ask what it buys before you pay it.

Sources

  1. SpeedyIndex study of 15,389 bought backlinks, via Cantech Letter (November 6, 2026)
  2. Searchlab: link building statistics 2026 (compilation)
  3. Google Search Central: spam policies for Google web search
  4. BacklinkURLs methodology

Last updated Methodology